Potluck: Failure, Faith, and Finishing Well
with James Floyd
As Season Two of The Last Service Podcast comes to a close, host Matt McGee sits down for a relaxed, wide-ranging “potluck conversation” with pastor, veteran, and discipleship leader James Floyd. This episode blends humor, hard-won wisdom, and deep theological reflection as they explore failure, identity, finishing well, church decline, and what it really means to follow Jesus beyond platforms and programs.
James shares his journey from military service to ministry, his leap into faith-based entrepreneurship, and the formation of his men’s discipleship work and Substack Jesus for Breakfast. Together, Matt and James reflect on why failure is often where God does His most formative work, why churches struggle with endings, and how discipleship—not branding—remains the heart of a faithful church.
This episode is especially meaningful for pastors, church leaders, and Christians navigating seasons of transition, decline, or uncertainty, offering hope rooted not in outcomes, but in intimacy with God.
Key Topics Discussed
Faith, failure, and identity beyond success
Lessons from military leadership and ministry
Why men often tie identity to work and results
What it means to “finish well” as a Christian
Church decline, consolidation, and discipleship models
Letting go of control and trusting God with outcomes
Why discipleship is slow, costly, and essential
Faithfulness in ordinary life: work, family, and service
